Magic Puzzle Company Guide 2026 – All 18 Puzzles and Where to Start

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. It costs you nothing extra.

Colorful jigsaw puzzle pieces, a blank envelope and a mug of tea on a sunny wooden table

A normal jigsaw puzzle ends the moment you click in the last piece. You look at the picture you already saw on the box for three days, say “nice”, and put it back in the box.

Magic Puzzle Company puzzles don’t stop there. They are 1,000-piece jigsaws with a surprise ending, designed together with professional magicians. When you finish, the puzzle does a trick, and the picture turns into something you didn’t see coming. That twist is why they’re my favorite puzzle gift right now.

There are now 18 puzzles in six series, plus a brand-new food spin-off, and the boxes all look alike from a distance. So this guide puts every puzzle in one place: what’s in the box, how big it gets, how hard each one is, how the “magic” works (no spoilers) and which one to buy first. We checked the whole catalog against the maker’s shop and recent reviews in October 2026.

Quick picks:

  • Best first puzzle: The Mystic Maze (Series 1)
  • Hardest: The Happy Isles, with The Drippy Trip close behind
  • Best for Halloween: The Spooky Shire (Series 6)
  • Newest: The Wild Wizards (Series 6)
  • Best value: any 3-pack bundle, which also gets free US shipping from the maker
  • For the foodie: the new Tasty Puzzles line

Magic Puzzle Company at a Glance

Every puzzle follows the same recipe, which makes the specs easy:

  • Pieces: 1,000, custom cut so the little jokes in the art don’t get chopped in half
  • Finished size: 28 x 21 inches
  • Price: $24.99 per puzzle and $64.99 per 3-pack at the maker’s shop (October 2026)
  • In the box: two art posters, so two people can work at once, an Easter egg checklist, reusable envelopes and a sealed envelope for the ending
  • Board: 100% recycled, FSC-certified “blue core” board and soy-based ink, according to the maker
  • Age: the maker doesn’t give one. Target lists the puzzles as 15 and up

The maker also says every puzzle is sifted by hand, so there’s very little puzzle dust. They claim the most dust they ever measured in a box was a quarter of a gram, about a third of one piece.

What Is the Magic Puzzle Company?

The Magic Puzzle Company was started by Max Temkin and Ben Hantoot, two of the co-founders of Cards Against Humanity. Magicians Jordan Gold and Simon Coronel helped design the tricks. The first puzzles launched on Kickstarter in 2020 and raised about $3.4 million from more than 62,000 backers, against a goal of about $44,000. That’s a lot of people who wanted their puzzles to misbehave.

Every puzzle has original art by a different illustrator, packed with small details and Easter eggs. The maker is loud about what’s not in the box: no stock images, no AI art and no single-use plastic. You can buy them from the maker’s site, Amazon, Target and Walmart.

How Does the Magic Ending Work?

Two kraft envelopes from The Mystic Maze; one says "Stop! Only open this envelope when you're done with the puzzle."

Without spoilers: the box has a sealed envelope with a big “Stop!” on it. You open it only after the main puzzle is done. What’s inside finishes the story of the picture, with an illusion that makes you look at the whole scene in a new way. The maker calls it the “Magic Shift”.

Reviewers describe it as a clever reveal, not a brain-melting one. Room Escape Artist wrote that the twist “isn’t going to completely melt your brain”, and that is fair. The fun is the moment you get it. Then you want to show it to everybody in the house.

Four things to know before you start, so you don’t wreck the trick:

  1. Build it from the poster. The ending depends on the finished picture. An Everyday Reading commenter who went freestyle said the puzzle had no magic ending at all.
  2. Leave the “Stop!” envelope alone. Opening it first is the one guaranteed way to spoil it.
  3. Use a big, smooth table. The maker asks for a table “a few feet larger” than 28 x 21 inches, because you will slide parts of the finished puzzle around.
  4. Skip the felt mat for the finale. The maker says felt and rubber puzzle mats “aren’t great” for this, for the same sliding reason. A roll-up mat like the Marbs puzzle mat is fine for storing it between sessions. Just finish on the bare table.

The honest downside: the trick works the same way in every box. Room Escape Artist says it’s still cool the second time, but it “isn’t surprising” anymore. You buy the second one for the art and the jokes, not for the shock.

Every Magic Puzzle Compared

Difficulty is what reviewers and buyers report, where they report it. A dash means nobody I could find wrote about it yet.

SeriesPuzzleArtistThe storyDifficulty
1The Mystic MazeBoya SunA yellow-suited hero searches an enchanted mazeEasiest, fast
1The Happy IslesSarah BecanThe fate of a bright island paradiseHard
1The Sunny CityFelicia ChiaoA hand-drawn city with a sunny secretLooks harder than it is
2The Busy BistroOscar SunWhy are these rats so busy?Medium
2The Crystal CavesOdsanyuAn ancient, bitter rivalry–
2The Forest FeastSanne-Marie KohlmannThe inspiration for an epic feast–
3The Secret SoupMargaux PeltatSave your friends from becoming soup–
3The Puzzled PatronTaylor RoseA crowded, fantastical tavern–
3The Gnomes’ HomesNinn SalaünSomeone is coming for the gnomes–
4Big Rock CityAnnika BrandowA dinosaur city with a BIG problem–
4The Awakened ArtifactsKathleen FuA museum whose exhibits went missing–
4The Peckish PiratesGozzPirates who bit off more than they can chew–
5The Drippy TripGHOSTSHRIMPA psychedelic toy-box dream worldVery hard
5The Golden GooseAnine BosenbergAesop’s greedy cottagers–
5The Coveted CometSamuel HaywardMiners on a comet, and something belowChallenging
6The Spooky ShireKasey UhterA haunted hillside party–
6The Wild WizardsStifflizardWizards running wild–
6The Stilted CityNot announcedComing soon–

Which Magic Puzzle Should You Start With?

The maker’s own advice: pick the artist or the world you like the most. Fair, but not very helpful when you’re staring at eighteen boxes.

Start with The Mystic Maze. Room Escape Artist ranked it first of the original three: “If you only ever do one of these, The Mystic Maze was a knockout.” They also solved it faster than any other 1,000-piece puzzle they had done, partly because most of the picture comes together early. That makes it a low-risk way to find out if you like the format.

If you already do hard puzzles for fun, start with The Happy Isles instead. If you want something new that a puzzle fan probably doesn’t own yet, go for Series 5 or 6.

Series 1 – the Original Three

The 2020 Kickstarter puzzles. They are still the most reviewed, and still sold.

The Mystic Maze – the Best First Puzzle

Box of The Mystic Maze, a 1000-piece puzzle from the Magic Puzzle Company

A yellow-suited hero hunts for a lost friend through an enchanted maze, drawn by Boya Sun. This is the one most people start with, and reviewers agree it’s the right call. The con is that it’s the gentlest one, so a seasoned puzzler may finish it in a weekend and want more. It’s for first-timers and for gifts when you don’t know the person’s puzzle level.

The Happy Isles – the Hard One

Box of The Happy Isles, a 1000-piece puzzle from the Magic Puzzle Company

A bright island paradise by Sarah Becan, with an unexpected fate for the people who live there. Everyday Reading called it “on the more tricky side”, and it took two people several days. Room Escape Artist found it “intimidating” and suggests doing The Mystic Maze first. Buy it for someone who finds normal 1,000-piece puzzles too easy.

The Sunny City – the Underdog

Box of The Sunny City, a 1000-piece puzzle from the Magic Puzzle Company

Felicia Chiao drew a warm, hand-illustrated city with a “sunny secret”. Room Escape Artist says it “looked far more daunting than it was”, which is good news. They ranked it third of the three, though, because the ending had less foreshadowing and buildup than the other two. Get it to complete Series 1, or if you like quiet, cozy art more than busy scenes.

See it at Magic Puzzle Company

Series 2 – Rats, Caves and a Feast

The Busy Bistro – Rats Running a Restaurant

Box of The Busy Bistro, a 1000-piece puzzle from the Magic Puzzle Company

A packed restaurant run by very busy rats, drawn by Oscar Sun. The puzzle asks you to figure out the big reason they’re rushing. Goods.Observer, a review site, called the challenge level “just right”. If rats in a kitchen make you think of a certain animated movie, you’re the target audience. If rats in a kitchen make you lose your appetite, pick another one.

The Crystal Caves – Pink, Glittery and Ancient

Box of The Crystal Caves, a 1000-piece puzzle from the Magic Puzzle Company

The most pink puzzle in the lineup, by the artist Odsanyu, about the end of an ancient and bitter rivalry. All that pink means large areas in similar colors, so on paper it’s a good pick for people who like sorting by shade. I couldn’t find a proper review of this one yet, so it’s a pick for fans of the art more than a safe first buy.

The Forest Feast – a Woodland Dinner Party

Box of The Forest Feast, a 1000-piece puzzle from the Magic Puzzle Company

Sanne-Marie Kohlmann drew a forest full of animals getting ready for an epic feast, and the ending reveals what inspired it. One gift roundup names it as a family pick. There are no independent reviews with real detail yet, so I can’t tell you how hard it is. It’s for families and anyone who likes cute animals more than haunted houses.

Series 3 – Soup, a Tavern and Gnomes

The Secret Soup – Don’t Become Dinner

Box of The Secret Soup, a 1000-piece puzzle from the Magic Puzzle Company

Margaux Peltat drew a snowy scene where you have to save your friends from being made into soup. It used to be a regular in Amazon deals, but at the time of writing (October 2026) Amazon wants about 37 bucks for it, so the maker’s own $24.99 is the better deal. What bugs me is the big white, snowy area on the box art: white is every puzzler’s least favorite job. Get it if you like a little danger with your cozy.

See it at Magic Puzzle Company

The Puzzled Patron – a Crowded Fantasy Tavern

Box of The Puzzled Patron, a 1000-piece puzzle from the Magic Puzzle Company

Taylor Rose drew a crowded, fantastical tavern, and the twist tells you what’s really going on there. It’s a natural fit for anyone who plays Dungeons & Dragons. No reviewer has gone into its difficulty yet, which is the con: you’re buying on the art. Give it to the friend who runs the game night.

See it at Magic Puzzle Company

The Gnomes’ Homes – a Fan Favorite

Box of The Gnomes' Homes, a 1000-piece puzzle from the Magic Puzzle Company

“Oh no! They’re coming for the Gnomes!” That’s the whole maker pitch, and Ninn Salaün’s art fills in the rest. One reader in the Everyday Reading comments lists it among their favorites. No named reviewer has rated its difficulty, though, so you’re trusting the fans. It belongs with anyone who has a garden gnome on the porch, obviously.

Series 4 – Dinosaurs, a Museum and Pirates

Big Rock City – Dinosaurs With a Big Problem

Box of Big Rock City, a 1000-piece puzzle from the Magic Puzzle Company

A busy prehistoric city of dinosaurs by Annika Brandow, facing a BIG problem. If you know anything about dinosaurs, you can guess the general direction, but not how the puzzle shows it. It’s one of the most searched-for titles, and the same Everyday Reading commenter puts it on their favorites list. The downside is the dense, green-heavy art, which means a lot of similar pieces. Made for dinosaur kids who grew up into dinosaur adults.

See it at Magic Puzzle Company

The Awakened Artifacts – a Night at the Museum

Box of The Awakened Artifacts, a 1000-piece puzzle from the Magic Puzzle Company

Kathleen Fu drew a marvelous museum where the exhibits have gone missing. It’s the third puzzle on that commenter’s favorites list. Cheapism’s reviewer calls the whole line “less on the pull-your-hair-out difficult side”, but nobody has rated this one on its own yet, and that’s the con. Good for museum people.

The Peckish Pirates – a Hungry Crew

Box of The Peckish Pirates, a 1000-piece puzzle from the Magic Puzzle Company

An eager pirate crew by the artist Gozz, who “may have bitten off more than they can chew”. The box art has a lot of green and a long white river, so expect a stretch of slow sorting. I found little detailed review coverage. Pirate fans, this is yours, and so is anyone who already owns the rest of Series 4.

See it at Magic Puzzle Company

Series 5 – the Trippy Ones

Series 5 arrived in two steps: The Drippy Trip in August 2025, the other two in January 2026.

The Drippy Trip – the Most Searched, and the Hardest

Box of The Drippy Trip, a 1000-piece puzzle from the Magic Puzzle Company

“A kaleidoscopic dream world straight out of a psychedelic toy box”, drawn by the artist GHOSTSHRIMP. It’s the most searched-for single puzzle of the bunch. Target buyers rate it 4.6 out of 5, and they warn that it is “Extremely challenging!” and “Not recommended for beginners”. A few also report missing or duplicate pieces and sides that don’t quite connect. For experienced puzzlers who like color chaos.

The Golden Goose – an Aesop Fable

Box of The Golden Goose, a 1000-piece puzzle from the Magic Puzzle Company

Anine Bosenberg’s take on the Aesop fable about the goose that lays golden eggs, and the greedy owners who want all the gold at once. You know how that story ends. You don’t know how the puzzle tells it. It’s one of the newer ones, so I found no detailed reviews yet. For people who like storybook art more than busy crowd scenes.

The Coveted Comet – the Upside-Down Puzzle

Box of The Coveted Comet, a 1000-piece puzzle from the Magic Puzzle Company

Two groups race to mine a comet, and something underneath has waited a long time to be found. Samuel Hayward drew it, and it’s the maker’s first “ambidirectional” puzzle: you can solve it right side up or upside down. It also introduced “conjoined whimsy pieces”, pairs of special pieces that belong together. One Target buyer called it “challenging but not frustrating”, but there are only a handful of ratings so far. For space nerds and for fans who think they’ve seen every trick.

Series 6 – New in 2026

Series 6 is this year’s series. Two of the three puzzles are out, and the third is on its way.

The Spooky Shire – the Halloween Puzzle

Box of The Spooky Shire, a 1000-piece puzzle from the Magic Puzzle Company

“Welcome, foolish mortals.” Kasey Uhter drew a haunted hillside where spirits and monsters meet once a year for the spookiest party of them all. It’s the company’s first puzzle of 2026, and according to Zatu it reached stores before it showed up on the maker’s own site. US searches for it jumped to about 1,000 in September. It’s very seasonal, though, which makes it a strange choice for a summer birthday. Buy it for Halloween people, which is to say people with a skeleton on the porch in August.

The Wild Wizards – the Newest Puzzle

Box of The Wild Wizards, a 1000-piece puzzle from the Magic Puzzle Company

The maker’s shop labels this one “Latest Puzzle!”. The artist Stifflizard drew a crowd of wizards running wild and “manifesting mayhem”. The product page opens with a quote from The Hobbit, which tells you the mood. It’s so new that I found no reviews yet, and that’s the con. For the fantasy fan who already did The Puzzled Patron.

The Stilted City – Coming Soon

The third Series 6 puzzle is listed on the maker’s site as “In Stock Soon”, for $24.99. There is no box image, no artist name and no release date yet, so there’s nothing to show here. The Series 6 bundle is also marked coming soon. I’ll add both once they ship.

Are the 3-Pack Bundles Worth It?

If you already know you like them, yes. On the maker’s site a bundle is $64.99 instead of $75 for three singles. A $64.99 order also gets free shipping in the continental US, so a bundle ships free and a single puzzle doesn’t. Three puzzles is about a month of weekends for most people.

Series 1 bundle: The Mystic Maze, The Happy Isles and The Sunny City stacked

Series 1 is the classic place to start, with the easiest and the hardest puzzle in one stack.

Series 2 bundle: The Busy Bistro, The Crystal Caves and The Forest Feast stacked

Series 3 bundle: The Secret Soup, The Puzzled Patron and The Gnomes' Homes stacked

Series 4 bundle: Big Rock City, The Awakened Artifacts and The Peckish Pirates stacked

Series 4 and 5 are the safest bets for a fan who started in 2020 or 2021: they’re the ones they’re least likely to own.

Series 5 bundle: The Drippy Trip, The Golden Goose and The Coveted Comet stacked

Tasty Puzzles – the New Food Spin-Off

The Tasty Puzzles Series One bundle, four food-photo puzzle boxes stacked

The newest thing from the company isn’t a Magic Puzzle at all. Tasty Puzzle Company is a sister line made by the Magic Puzzle Company, with food photography instead of illustrations.

Series One has three 1,000-piece puzzles of famous American restaurants: Franklin Barbecue (Austin), Gage & Tollner (Brooklyn) and Oyster Oyster (Washington, D.C.). They’re $24.99 each. The $99 bundle adds a fourth puzzle you can’t buy separately, “Special Order #1” by co-founder Kevin Pang. They also have “Wonky Tabs” for splitting the puzzle among a group.

The catch: it’s pre-order only and sold only on Tasty’s own site, in limited numbers. The first printing is promised “in time for Christmas”, and a second printing in spring 2027. The maker doesn’t mention a magic ending, so don’t expect a trick. It’s a fun one for the barbecue fan who has already done every Magic Puzzle.

See it at Tasty Puzzle Company

Are Magic Puzzles a Good Gift?

They’re one of the safest gifts for anybody who already does jigsaws. A few tips:

  • Check what they own. Fans collect them, so Series 5 or 6 is the least likely to be a duplicate.
  • Match the difficulty. The Mystic Maze for a beginner, The Happy Isles or The Drippy Trip for someone who needs a challenge.
  • Warn them about the envelope. A sticky note on the box that says “don’t open the Stop! envelope first” saves the trick.
  • Think about table space. If their table is also the dinner table, pair it with a roll-up Marbs puzzle mat for the in-between days.
  • Not for small kids. Target says 15 and up, and the art is full of tiny details. A patient younger kid can help an adult with it.

Want something even meaner for the puzzle lover in your life? Look at our challenging gifts for puzzle lovers, go all in with a 40,000-piece Disney puzzle, or browse our gifts for board game lovers.

FAQ

How big is a finished Magic Puzzle?

28 x 21 inches. Plan for a table a few feet larger than that, because the ending needs room to move parts of the puzzle around.

How many pieces does a Magic Puzzle have?

Every Magic Puzzle is 1,000 pieces. The sealed envelope adds extra pieces for the ending, so the true total is higher. Reviewers counted anywhere from about 50 to about 80 extra pieces.

How hard are Magic Puzzles?

Most are a normal 1,000-piece challenge with a lot of detail to help you. The Mystic Maze is the easiest, and The Happy Isles and The Drippy Trip are the hardest according to reviewers and buyers.

What age are Magic Puzzles for?

The maker doesn’t give an age. Target lists them as 15 and up. Cheapism suggests 10 and up for kids, with an adult nearby.

How long does a Magic Puzzle take?

That depends on the puzzle and the puzzlers. Reviewers report anything from a fast weekend for The Mystic Maze to several days for two people on The Happy Isles.

Do you need to do the puzzles in order?

No. Every puzzle has its own art and its own trick. The series numbers only show when they came out.

How many Magic Puzzles are there?

There are 18 puzzles in six series (three per series), and The Stilted City, the last of them, is still coming soon. There is no Series 7 announced yet.

What if a piece is missing?

The company replaces missing pieces wherever you bought the puzzle. You pay the postage (about 5 bucks in the US), it only covers new puzzles, and there’s a limit of two replacements per customer. Contact details are on the maker’s site.

Is the Magic Puzzle Company legit?

Yes. It’s a real company that has sold its puzzles since the 2020 Kickstarter, through its own shop and big US stores. Co-founder Max Temkin left in 2020, after misconduct allegations at Cards Against Humanity. Ben Hantoot and the team still run the puzzle company.

Where can I buy Magic Puzzles?

From the maker’s site, Amazon, Target and Walmart. The maker’s site is $24.99 per puzzle, and Amazon often has one or two on sale.